By Mike Millett · November 18, 2026
At 1:37 on a Wednesday afternoon a business got an email from me. At 1:52 it ran its own AI visibility check. At 1:53 it asked for the full report and gave us an email address to send it to. Sixteen minutes, start to finish, from a stranger's inbox to a lead.
- 1:37The email lands
- 1:52They run their own check
- 1:53They ask for the full report
It is one business. We have emailed 87 since October 10, and this is the first one that went and ran the check itself. Is one lead a lot? No. Am I celebrating like it is? Yes. (haha)
I mean that. Celebrate the small stuff. But the lead is not the most useful part of the day. The most useful part is what happened the same afternoon, when I said what I was scared of.
What the email actually says
The email is short on purpose. Here is one from this week, with the business taken out.
Subject The first fix AIOInsights found for [their website]
Hi [first name],
We ran [their website] through AIOInsights today. It checks how AI assistants read a business's website. The first fix it found: your reviews aren't in your structured data. Structured data is the part of a page written for machines to read.
Your free check shows the rest: [their check]
If this is not useful, just tell me and I will not write again.
Digilu
9345 Rhea Ave, Northridge, CA 91324
There is no offer in it. No price, no "quick call", no ask beyond looking at something true about your own business. If the finding is wrong, the email is worthless, so the finding has to be right.
What it took to send one
We worked on this together for days. Most of the work is the list of reasons an email is not allowed to go.
Before anything sends, the system checks that the draft is finished, that we have never written to this business before, that the address has not bounced before, and that the domain can actually receive mail. A separate reviewer scores the exact text of each email, and anything under 9 out of 10 is held. Then I see the batch and approve it. Even after that, the emails go out one at a time, close to a minute apart, never in a burst. I am on blind copy of every one.
That is a lot of machinery for a short email. It is supposed to be. The whole point is that a stranger can trust it.
The same day, I got scared
Our outreach goes out from our real domain. If it gets marked as spam, all of that goes to the junk folder with it, and you do not get to pick which mail suffers.
So I said it out loud: "Don't get my domain marked as spamming."
The answer we built is a limit that watches how the last emails landed. Bounces, complaints, and people asking us to stop all pull the daily number down on their own. A single spam complaint stops sending entirely. Our sending provider rates the domain healthy today, and the limit is there so I am not the one who has to notice when that changes.
One option was on the table: send the outreach from a second domain, so ours stays clean no matter what happens. I said no. We follow the rules. We have integrity.
If an email is good enough to send, it is good enough to send from our real name.
The rules are not complicated
In the US, the FTC's guide to CAN-SPAM says a commercial email must include a valid physical postal address, must explain clearly how to opt out, and must honor an opt-out within 10 business days. It also says not to use deceptive subject lines or misleading header information. It applies to all commercial email, not just bulk mail.
Gmail's sender guidelines add a number. Keep the spam rate reported in Google's Postmaster Tools below 0.10%, and avoid ever reaching 0.30%. That is fewer than one complaint in a thousand. You do not hit that by sending a lot of email people did not ask for. You hit it by sending email people are glad they got.
Do that math at our size. One complaint out of our 121 emails is about 0.8%. That is nearly three times the line Google says never to reach. At low volume there is no cushion. That is why one complaint stops everything.
Why a few beats a lot
Volume is the easy way out. Send enough and something lands. The cost of that is paid by your domain and by every person who had to delete you.
The other way is to pick the business carefully and tell them one true thing about their own website that they did not know. You need far fewer emails that way, because each one is doing real work. One lead from 87 is small. It came from telling the truth first.
Where I could be wrong
One lead is an anecdote, not a result. Sixteen minutes could be curiosity, not intent. I do not know yet whether it becomes a conversation, and I will not know for a while.
The other numbers matter more. Of the 121 emails we have sent, four went to addresses that bounced. That is about 3%. It means some of the addresses we found were not real, and a bounce is a small strike against the domain every time. Sending less email does not fix that. Checking the address before it is queued does.
The rules are the floor. The person on the other end still did not ask for this email.
And the limit is a setting we chose, not a standard anyone published. If the complaints stay at zero and the leads keep coming, the limit will have been too cautious.
If you send email to people who did not ask for it, run a simple test on yourself. Put your real address at the bottom. Put a one-line way out in the body, and honor it the same day. Say one thing in the first two sentences that is true and specific to the person reading. Count your bounces and your opt-outs every week.
“I was scared about spam, and rightfully so, but it is working.”
One lead. Zero complaints. Sixteen minutes.
Further reading
- Federal Trade Commission, 'CAN-SPAM Act: A Compliance Guide for Business'. The source of the postal address, opt-out, 10 business day and subject line rules. ftc.gov/business-guidance/resources/can-spam-act-compliance-guide-business
- Google, 'Email sender guidelines', Gmail Help. The source of the 0.10% and 0.30% spam rate figures. support.google.com/a/answer/81126